Email Forwarding Rules: The Hack a New Password Misses

Email Forwarding Rules: How Hackers Keep Reading Your Mail After a Password Change

Email forwarding rules are small instructions inside a mailbox that send, move or delete messages automatically. They are an ordinary convenience, and criminals who break into a business email account use them to keep reading it, and to hide what they are doing, long after the password has been changed. For a small business, the practical lesson is simple: a hacked mailbox is not cleaned up until someone has checked every rule inside it.

This article explains how these rules work, how they are used in invoice fraud, what Microsoft blocks by default, and the questions to put to your IT provider after any break-in.

What an Email Rule Does

Most people have set up a rule at some point without thinking of it as a security setting. Newsletters go to a folder, messages from the accountant get flagged, and copies of order confirmations go to a colleague.

A rule runs on its own, every time a message arrives, whether or not anyone opens the mailbox. That is exactly what makes it useful to an intruder. Once it exists, it keeps working in the background without anyone having to sign in again.

How Criminals Turn Email Forwarding Rules Against You

When criminals get into a business mailbox, usually through a stolen password, their goal is often money: to send fake invoices or new bank details to your clients and suppliers at the right moment. For that, they need to read the right conversations and keep the real owner of the mailbox from noticing. Rules do both jobs.

Forwarding. A rule sends a copy of every email containing words such as invoice, payment or wire to an outside address. The intruder no longer needs to sign in to follow your billing conversations.

Hiding. A rule moves replies from a particular client or supplier into a folder nobody opens, or deletes them. When the real client writes to ask why they were sent new bank details, the question never reaches your team.

The FBI described both techniques in a 2020 warning to businesses. In one case it cited, criminals set up rules inside a manufacturing company’s mailbox that forwarded any message containing the words bank, payment, invoice, wire or check. In another, at a medical equipment company, the criminals used hidden rules and a fake supplier address to obtain $175,000.

Why Changing the Password Is Not Enough

Changing the password stops the intruder from signing in with the old one. It does not delete the rules they already created, because those rules live in the mailbox itself, independently of the password.

There is a second trap. The FBI warning explained that rules created in the web version of an email account do not always appear in the desktop email program. So an IT person who opens the employee’s computer and looks at the usual settings can conclude that everything is clean while a forwarding rule keeps running on the server.

Finally, an intruder may still have an open sign-in session, the kind that keeps you logged in on a phone for weeks. Unless someone cancels those sessions, the old access can keep working for a while even after the password changes.

What Microsoft Blocks by Default, and What It Does Not

Microsoft 365, which many small businesses use for email, has a company-wide setting that controls whether mailboxes may automatically forward messages to outside addresses. According to Microsoft’s own documentation, the default changed in 2021: for new organizations, and for existing ones that were not relying on it, automatic forwarding to outside addresses is switched off.

However, Microsoft also notes that some older organizations can still have it switched on under the same default label, and it recommends choosing the setting explicitly. So the answer for your company depends on when your account was set up and what your provider has done since.

There is also a limit to what this setting covers. It stops messages from being forwarded outside the company. It does not stop rules that move or delete messages inside a mailbox, which are the rules that hide the fraud from your own team.

Signs That Someone May Have Set Up a Rule

You will not see a rule unless you look for it. The signs that one exists usually show up in your relationships first.

  • A client or supplier mentions an email from you that nobody remembers sending.
  • Replies that someone was waiting for never arrive, especially about invoices or payments.
  • Messages appear in folders such as Archive, RSS Subscriptions or Conversation History without anyone moving them there.
  • A colleague receives a bounce message about an email they never sent.

Any one of these is a reason to ask your IT provider to review the mailbox concerned, today.

A Decision Only the Owner Can Make

Some employees forward work email to a personal address on purpose, to read it on a home computer or keep a copy when they travel. Each of those email forwarding rules looks exactly like the ones intruders create, which makes the malicious ones much harder to spot.

So decide, as a company policy, whether anyone may forward company email to an outside address, and if so, who approves it and how it is recorded. Most small businesses can say no outright. Once that rule is written down, your IT provider can block outside forwarding for everyone and treat any new forwarding rule as a warning sign, because no legitimate one should exist.

Questions to Ask Your IT Provider

These questions tell you whether email forwarding rules are being watched in your company, or only noticed by accident.

  • Is automatic forwarding to outside addresses switched off for our whole company, and was it set explicitly? A good answer is yes, with the date it was checked.
  • Would you be alerted if someone created a new forwarding or deleting rule in one of our mailboxes? Ask how quickly, and who receives the alert.
  • After a hacked mailbox, do you check the rules on the server itself, or only on the employee’s computer? The answer should be the server.
  • When you reset a password after a break-in, do you also cancel every open sign-in? This is what actually removes the intruder’s existing access.

What to Do After a Hacked Mailbox

If you learn that an employee’s email account was used by someone else, the password change is only the first step of the cleanup. Ask your IT provider to confirm, in writing, that they have:

  1. Reset the password and required the code on the employee’s phone for every future sign-in.
  2. Cancelled every open sign-in session for that account.
  3. Listed every rule in the mailbox, on the server, and removed any that nobody can explain.
  4. Checked whether the same rules or forwarding addresses appear in other mailboxes.
  5. Reviewed which emails were sent from the account during the break-in.

Then warn the clients and suppliers who were in recent contact with that mailbox. Tell them by phone, on a number you already have, that any change of bank details must be confirmed the same way. If money has already moved, call your bank immediately and file a complaint with the FBI at ic3.gov.

A Rule Is a Small Thing That Stays

Email forwarding rules are easy to create and easy to forget, which is exactly why intruders like them. A new password closes the front door. The rule check closes the window the intruder left open on the way out. Making that check a standard part of every mailbox cleanup costs your IT provider very little time, and it removes one of the quietest ways that invoice fraud keeps going after everyone thinks it is over.

Share this
Picture of Alchanis Technical
Alchanis Technical

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *